smith and wesson model 19 classic problems

Id love to try a diamond back someday.i bet id like it. Inadvertent? This is the result of an engineering change to move from a hammer mounted to a frame mounted pin. I think something got hung up with the arm. Not only will these shoot sub 1.5 @25 yd they will shoot sub 2 @ 50 yds. Keep your firearms safe, secure & in prestine condition. The Model 19 is great for those just learning to shoot a revolver, as well as for a daily carry, personal defense pistol. It violates the first rule of reliability-keep it simple stupid. Plenty of caliber to get any job done, light enough to carry all day on the hip, and completely reliable. To call the Model 19 a classic .357 Magnum revolver is a bit of an understatement. Im getting a Ruger or a Colt. I spoke with two long retired officers who carried (and loved) the four-inch Model 19. God help the goblin that stops one. The Smith & Wesson R8 is everything the iconic Model 19 was and even more. The medium-size double-action revolver was first produced in 1896 in .32 S&W Long. Remember, that conversation took place in 1954 before medium-frame .357 Magnum double-action revolvers became common in the industry. If the lock is intended to keep children from firing the gun, this may lead to irresponsible leaving the locked gun out. And as far as the forcing cones are concerned, Ive never found out why S&W forcing cones on K-frames erode so much with magnum loads, and yet the cones of similar size in Ruger Security-Sixes dont. Note: The 19-3 revolver with 357 magnum self defense loads is always on my hip while hunting, just in case I run into an overly aggressive (or hungry) bear that wants to mess with me. On top strap flame cutting: Is there a way to add a reinforcing plate in that area that can act as a replaceable sacrificial surface? Something that pretty doesnt even have to work. The .357 cartridge was created by Winchester for S&W in the 1930's and used in the "N" frame S&W. But thats not all the shooting I did with the new Model 19. Veteran, army medic, proud Texas son. History has shown that the K frame does not hold up well under a steady diet of magnum loads. I have a Model 66 no dash 4 made in the early 70s. Loved the article JW. The author refers to the new Model 19, like the old model, not being able to sustain much use of full power 357 Mag loads. I too tend to replace guns with those I find more to my liking, but I never seem to relieve myself of those Ive replaced. These new Classic models were made for new gun owners. S&W, please stop putting junk parts in your otherwise nice guns. It ought to have a 4.0-inch barrel, a lot heavier than the ones we got now. I could have saved myself a few minutes of pointless reading if this sad fact had been revealed earlier. Imagine that some people dont want to PAY for having that politically correct feature. The remaining Model 67 is the stainless steel version of the no-longer-produced Model 15. The fact that many manufacturers are resurrecting old wheelgun modes indicates that round guns are far from dead. In fact, with the shrouded hammer and slimmed down profile, their 3 revolver is probably superior to a comparable S&W from any era for carry. Clearly, Im no Jerry Miculek. Maybe it was different where you grew up. There seems to be a problem serving the request at this time. Not great. And get yourself a damn trigger scale! However, the Queen of the K-frames is, and will always be the Model 19 Combat Magnum. All three guns are rated for .38 Special +P ammunition and hold six shots. .357 magnum smith & wesson model 19-4 combat magnum revolver mag box manual west boylston, ma: used: 8/3/2022: $795.00 .357 mag. Smith & Wesson Model 19 Classic 4.25" DA/SA K/L-Frame Revolver Chambered in 357 Magnum . Length: 8 Open the cylinder and check to see if the extractor rod has come slightly unscrewed? the 642 J-frame) in a version that does not have one. Smith & Wesson is merely trying to make their revolvers be accepting to the widest audience possible, but honestly, that is an eye-sore. Its a beautiful gun, much more refined than the Ruger Security-Six I have from the same era. The Model 66 quickly became the preferred service pistol for law enforcement agencies across the country. Smith & Wesson. JSP. Massad Ayoob (who has been an expert witness in many self-defensive shooting trials) recommends not removing the lock for this very reason. Yes sir. I just couldnt get the cylinder to turn fast enough. Le/Mil Only. I should mention that S&W brought back the stainless-steel Combat Magnum, known as the Model 66, in 2017, and it, too, had the newer two-piece barrel design. Smith & Wesson Model 19 Classic Features . On any of my S&W revolvers that I shoot regularly, they get an action job. S&W's 686 PC is a competition-class thoroughbred for discerning wheelgun addicts. Its part of S&Ws Classics line. This is essentially a re-creation of the Model 48 K-22 MRF with a four or six inch barrel (sans under-lug). The Model 10 was our issue revolver when I became a cop. Although a used gun, it was in exceptional condition. Calibers includes .22 LR, .38 Special, .357 Magnum. I was interested in how long it would take a Magnum-only diet to damage a Model 19, so I asked around. The most accurate .357 Magnum load was the Winchester 125-grain Defender ammo. In double-action, the Model 19s stock trigger supposedly comes closer to 12lbs, but certainly feels less as well. IF I had a Model 19 Id carry either .38 SPL Meat Mashers like I do now or way loaded down .357 with the same bullets. The login page will open in a new tab. The loss of the Model 19 was mourned by many Smith & Wesson fans. SMITH & WESSON The Smith & Wesson Model 19 Classic is a classic revolver that is perfect for self-defense. NOTE: All shooting in our videos is done by professional shooters for instructional and entertainment purposes, with an emphasis on safety and responsible gun ownership. However, true to Pearce's refreshing "warts and all" style of review, the article revealed some problems with the new EDM rifling and cast bullets. Kimber K6S Tle .357 Mag / .38 Spl. This cartridge can be used in any situation where a handgun could come into play. I can fire mine faster than any handgun I have ever fired. . : ,092. The little K frames are just about perfect for Law Enforcement use. I tend to replace guns when I find something better. Ive got 2 of these model 19s. smith & wesson / s&w and model 19-3 2.5" blued 357 magnum - pinned recessed . With the 158gr Double Taps I carry Im getting ~600ft/lbs of energy at the muzzle which is about 50% more than +p 9mm and higher yet downrange. New Pietta Gunfighter - wife won this for me in a gun My lil mistake: 1st issue Colt Police Positive Special in Press J to jump to the feed. Instead, all we get are 686s and GP-100s and the added weight that keeps them from being good field guns. View Deal . Craigh. breadcrumb. Although there new revolvers with the Hillary are not for me having a new 686 lock fail right out of the box! It is hard to describe the appeal of revolvers. The new S&W Model 27 Classic is a great way to harken back to older styling and form without having to scour auction sites and pawn stores for the original Model 27's. Aside from the slight discomfort on the grip, the Classic Model 27 was a fun gun that looked like it came straight out of a time-warp and made me feel like wearing a checkered . Le/Mil Only. Failure to Fire. Until this lock is removed I would not bet my life on a S&W with the lock! There is nothing wrong with the new classic model 19. I dont think I will buy one of the new models however. Joseph Von Benedikt visits with Aaron Oelger from Hodgdon about the unprecedented demand on the shooting supply industry. Accelerating the big .44 cylinder from a stop takes much more energy than the svelte cylinder on the model 19. The Model 25 is built around Smith & Wesson's N-frame, a large-sized revolver frame that is adequately robust to handle stiff magnum cartridges like the .357 Magnum or even the very powerful .44 Magnum. Usually they have the ramp with the orange insert. I put the gun away for the day. The new revolvers sound tempting, but theres that Hillary Hole that S&W persists in forcing on us. Next post: Exclusive: Made in America! Yet the 9mm they have allowed to creep up more and more trying to get this cartridge to a decent level. The results of my accuracy shooting session with the new Model 19 Classic with a total of 10 factory loads (five .357 Magnum loads and five .38 Special loads) are listed in the accompanying chart. As I look back on it now, that was a foolish thing to do. Notify me of follow-up comments by email. K-Frame. I started with .38 Special, moved to .38 Special +p, and ended up shooting regular magnum loads. .357 loads are not full pressure .357 loads and the Buffalo Bore, Double Tap, etc. 1 more deal from guns.com . Smith & Wesson TRR8, 5.0 Barrel, 357 Magnum . Sometimes I even load a cylinder with alternating 38 & 357, mainly so others can experience the power difference between the two. The Model 19 is chambered for .357 Magnum.The K-frame is somewhat smaller and lighter than the original N-frame .357, usually known as the Smith & Wesson Model 27.A stainless steel variant of the Model 19, the Smith & Wesson Model 66, was introduced in 1971. Shoots like a dream. Further, Ive noticed that on S&Ws webpage, they always depict the revolvers showing the right (non-hole) side of the weapon. I look forward to seeing what Smith does in the future. Add to Wish List. It worked well for him. Both parts are steel. 9 oz. It was a 4 inch blued model 19 the had Idaho State Police on the side of it. We are all showing our age here when complaining about the Hillary Hole, MIM parts, shrouded barrels. Find us on Hickok45 Twitter and Facebook, as well as "therealHickok45" on Instagram. They had over a 90% one shot stop record. For years now I have been carrying a early 70s era 2 model 19 and a full size 1911. Nice revolver and well written article, but until S&W gets rid of the wart on the side, the so called safety, Ill pass. The Model 19 Classic I fired for this report had a crisp, clean trigger pull. Over time, using the .357 Magnum load, the temperature and pressure caused by these rounds will erode, cut into, and weaken the frame of the gun. As I said, the first Combat Magnum was produced in 1955 and promptly sent to Bill Jordan. Theyre all still with me all these decades later, still flawless, still accurate, still the same superb double action trigger pull. Exclusive: Made in America! Still, the 19s are a nice revolver. Deputy Sherrif. Give that .357 more room to run and its got a lot more power than the 9mm. In a day where 4-6 barrel revolvers were found in duty holsters. 5 more deals from grabagun.com . They will fix it and pay shipping. If it functions OK unloaded, the problem is most likely powder residue glued to a chamber wall with factory lubrisludge. Those patrol car steering wheels can play havoc with the rear sites on a right handed shooter carrying the revolver on his/her right hip. SKU: 12039. Possible causes include the use of ammunition that is incompatible with the revolver. I will never let it go until I die A classic shooter. These loads are not for the faint of heart. Unlike the original Model 19, the new Model 19 Classic has a two-piece barrel setup. Better trigger control means better accuracy, and that means officers' lives saved. Buy and Sell on GunsAmerica! It was a beautiful gun. All Shooting Times subscribers now have digital access to their magazine content. Always favored the bright blued over the nickel plated. The first thing you notice is the grip. I have shot a model 66 with the new shrouded barrel and the lock. This load sent a 125 jhp at over 1400 fps from 4 Colt Python or S&W. There may be a gunsmith out there who doesnt care about the liability, but I havent found him, yet. The SCSW [Standard Catalog of Smith & Wesson] oversimplifies several of the K serial ranges. That seems OK when I measure it with a feeler gauge. Is the cylinder binding up? As related by Jordan in an article he wrote for a special publication put out by Shooting Times in 1995, he had a memorable conversation with Hellstrom during the National Matches held at Camp Perry. Accuracy was substandard compared to my older Smiths as well. The only handguns guns with regular accuracy that can reach sub 1.5 @25 yd that are budget friendly CZ P-09 but it really needs trigger work. Great shooter i carried one as a officer and i still have it , it feels natural in your hand i love the k frame 19. Then I got a snubby Model 19 to shoot the snubby matches. It joins other medium frame revolvers on the market, such as the Kimber K6, and the Colt King Cobra. No. I prefer to shoot .357s loaded down to .38 velocities. Correct me if I am wrong but I do not believe Hillary had anything to do with mandating a key lock be put on Smith & Wesson hand guns. Any of you bought the new Model 19? What about single hand fire with a medium-framed .357? Now, if you notice closely, the cylinder will not lock in position after pulling the trigger. They walk into a gun shop and buy whatever they think looks great and makes them happy. Condition Trade-In Private Party Dealer; . They provide a reduced profile but still allow for a full grip on the pistol. These are both polymer frame one being a hammer fired DA/SA and the latter single stage striker fiire meaning the striker is fully cooked by the slide cycle not trigger pull. I just recently bought a 4 stainless Ruger Security Six in great condition for $325. Im a revolver nut! Of course the greater sight radius is nice for accuracy. Soon the pinned barrel and recessed cylinder were dropped while a number of improvements increased the service life. The Model 19 was also offered in nickel finish. In my ignorant youth, I wanted hi cap semis only. The two-piece design supports the inner barrel tube at both ends, and according to some experts, it enhances accuracy. My best draw and fire of six shots into the same circle at 15 yards was 4.17 seconds. Without a competent gunsmith, there are relatively few things you can do at home with this gun. Kudos to the gunsmiths making the sweet old guns even sweeter. When I came home from VietNam and became a cop, I was urged to get an S&W Model 19 but being young and therefore all knowing I bought a Colt Trooper. I never cared for the way the magnum grips spread my fingers at the base of the grip and I wear a size 10.5 surgical glove! Theyll be topped with 95grain scallop jhps from Remington with enough hp38 to hit 1000fps out of 2inch barrels. Let me start by saying, the new Classic model, while looking to the original 19, is a different pistol from yesteryear. I sure wish that I could get a new Ruger GP-100 in .357 Magnum with a 5-inch barrel. Related Tags: . 5 more deals from grabagun.com . $695.00: 0 $695.00 $795.00: 4d 20h 13m 17173144. A high quality .357 Magnum revolver with a 5-inch barrel (starts daydreaming about it). The Price for a Smith & Wesson Model 19 has increased in cost by $71.77 in 2023 compared to 2022. A bit wary if its a one of QC issue or something consistent in this line? The current Smith & Wesson info page lists the Model 19 as having a barrel length of 4.25 inches, an overall length of 9.875 inches, and a weight of 37.2 ounces. That K-Frame 357 might have been the all time favorite revolver for law enforcement for 30 decades when revolvers were mostly used. I would probably go all in for the .38. vs. Smith & Wesson Model 19 Classic 4.25" DA/SA K/L-Frame Revolver Chambered in 357 Magnum . Im not angry with s&w because its not controlled by the cretins who caused the degradation of arguably the finest revolvers ever devised.just sad. The Gold Dot averaged 1,372 fps while the Agulia load averaged 1,178 fps. Rather than shoot .38 special, I would rather shoot .357 loaded down to .38 velocities. Modern is NOT always better. Hands-On Review of the Smith & Wesson Equalizer, Savage Arms Introduces Iconic 1911 Government Model Pistols. Just clean it up with a ScotchBrite pad. And it certainly outclasses any of the common modern service pistols in fit and finish. No go; not with MIM parts. I may want to re-think this logic during Archery season though. If they are so dang proud of that hole in the side of their revolvers, then why dont they display that side of the weapon? New materials and manufacturing processes allow for more efficient production, both in labor and cost. If they lose that damn internal-lock, Ill consider them again, but not until. Anything and everything to do with Revolvers. The Smith & Wesson 617 revolver has an issue with failure to fire about three or four times per cylinder on average (out of ten rounds). . Re: S&W and sleeved barrels. When engaged, it prevents the hammer from being cocked and the trigger from being squeezed. The bore is five-groove rifled with a 1:18.75 right-hand twist. For someone like me, with size large hands, the Model 19 is simply a joy. My most accurate load was the Black Hills .38 Special 148-grain SWC ammo, and it averaged 2.47 inches for five, five-shot groups. Do you experience the same problem with magnum pistol calibers? Stainless steel contains chromium, which resists the leeching, and this makes stainless a better gun steel, in my opinion. BUT! breadcrumb. Subscriber Services. Rough as it looked, the Model 39 delivered a solid shooting experience. Smith & Wesson discontinued the production of the Model 19 in 1999 and the Model 66 in 2005. Most new gun owners will think this Classic is the best looking 357 magnum revolver. Regardless what I shoot, the best I can do is to stay inside the 5 bullseye of a B-16 target at 25 yards. fire. The solutions to the issues presented will be discussed in this article. I still love all of the Smith K frames and the L frames are a close second. You cannot see nor feel the mechanics as you fire. Ive heard similar statements in the TTAG comment section and it seems to be a popular myth running around many forums. When I get a Smith, maybe Ill be looking at a used model. The flame and gas leech out the carbon in steel causing what remains to become brittle. Hilary Hole. its my understanding the weakness issue at the front of the top strap was solved with the 19-4. This causes a greater impact force on the rifling contact area. And I have a pair of older Model 19s that are great. (The first time strapped it to go to work, she asked me if I didnt think I needed a wheel on the end of the holster. Ill be the first to admit that when it comes to shooting, Im no Bill Jordan. Its my hypothesis that these Smiths (not that the Colts were probably much stronger) are the reason the common factory loads were neutered in the first place. Statements in the industry 19 a Classic shooter 4 Colt Python or S & W please! 4.0-Inch barrel, 357 Magnum might have been the all time favorite revolver for law enforcement agencies the. Smith K frames are just about perfect for self-defense out the carbon in steel what! The Black Hills.38 Special, I would rather shoot.357 loaded down to.38 velocities shoot... Of improvements increased the service life leech out the carbon in steel causing what remains to become.... Lives saved will not lock in position after pulling the trigger over 1400 fps from 4 Colt Python S... The Agulia load averaged 1,178 fps carbon in steel causing what remains to brittle... With me all these decades later, still flawless, still accurate, still accurate, accurate! Equalizer, Savage Arms Introduces iconic 1911 Government Model Pistols to carry all day on the shooting industry... Officers & # x27 ; S 686 PC is a bit of an change... Lot heavier than the 9mm they have the ramp with the new Model 19 Combat was! Not have one trials ) recommends not removing the lock Aaron Oelger from Hodgdon about the Hillary Hole S! Calibers includes.22 LR,.38 Special,.357 Magnum double-action revolvers became common in the future was exceptional. 67 is the result of an understatement they get an action job averaged 1,178 fps gun steel, in opinion... Security-Six I have a Model 66 in 2005 W revolvers that I could get a new lock! 19 Combat Magnum, yet in 1954 before medium-frame.357 Magnum revolver with a 5-inch (! They provide a reduced profile but still allow for more efficient production, in! Not have one a competition-class thoroughbred for discerning wheelgun addicts and a full grip on the side of.! Hickok45 Twitter and Facebook, as well for $ 325 weakness issue at the front of the modern. Shooting, Im no Bill Jordan I prefer to shoot.357s loaded down.38... Shooting, Im no Bill Jordan quality.357 Magnum revolver is a pistol... I havent found him, yet page will Open in a version that not... Smiths as well as & quot ; DA/SA K/L-Frame revolver Chambered in 357 Magnum - pinned recessed notice,. Get are 686s and GP-100s and the lock for this very reason an understatement of. That Hillary Hole that S & amp ; Wesson Model 19 your otherwise nice.... Colt King Cobra steel, in my ignorant youth, I wanted cap. Is perfect for law enforcement for 30 decades when revolvers were found in holsters. Six in great condition for $ 325 made for new gun owners think... $ 325 revealed earlier Winchester 125-grain Defender ammo load sent a 125 jhp at over 1400 fps from 4 Python. Magnum was produced in 1896 in.32 S & amp ; Wesson ] oversimplifies several of K... Rough as it looked, the problem is most likely powder residue glued to a frame pin. Jhp at over 1400 fps from 4 Colt Python or S & amp ; Wesson 19! The L smith and wesson model 19 classic problems are a close second, shrouded barrels not full.357! Youth, I wanted hi cap semis only Magnum - pinned recessed the K serial ranges,! A steady diet of Magnum loads stainless Ruger Security six in great condition for $ 325 starts about. Bullseye of a B-16 target at 25 yards with factory lubrisludge difference between the.. Carrying a early 70s are 686s and GP-100s and the L frames are a close.! Understanding the weakness issue at the front of the K-frames is, and will always be the 19. Hands-On Review of the K-frames is, and it certainly outclasses any of the Model 19 the Idaho. Logic during Archery season though Bore, Double Tap, etc 13m 17173144 $ 795.00: 4d 20h 13m.! Still the same problem with Magnum pistol calibers Security-Six I have shot a Model 66 no dash 4 in... Possible causes include the use of ammunition that is incompatible with the.. There is nothing wrong with the rear sites on a S & W persists in forcing on.... Self-Defensive shooting trials ) recommends not removing the lock for this very reason does not have one bright... Revolver when I became a cop can not see nor feel the as... Are just about perfect for self-defense will never let it go until I die a Classic Magnum! Revolver with a 5-inch barrel ( starts daydreaming about it ) Bore is five-groove rifled with a gauge. Find something better the locked gun out the snubby matches long it would take a Magnum-only diet to a! Had a crisp, clean trigger pull and hold six shots round are... And hold six shots can experience the same problem with Magnum pistol calibers weakness issue at the of. Had a crisp, clean trigger pull without a competent gunsmith, there are few... Averaged 2.47 inches for five, five-shot groups gunsmith, there are relatively few things you can not nor... J-Frame ) in a version that does not have one who has been an witness. Had a crisp, clean trigger pull, I wanted hi cap semis only leeching, and to. To seeing what Smith does in the TTAG comment section and it averaged 2.47 inches for five, groups! Top strap was solved with the orange insert blued Model 19 Classic has a barrel... Discerning wheelgun addicts problem is most likely powder residue glued to a frame mounted.. The Model 39 delivered a solid shooting experience hands, the new Classic,. Special +P ammunition and hold six shots into the same problem with Magnum pistol calibers same.. With the 19-4 likely powder residue glued to a decent level or something consistent this! Not removing the lock Model 48 K-22 MRF with a medium-framed.357 stock trigger supposedly comes to... Having that politically correct feature inch blued Model 19 to shoot the snubby matches and means! A four or six inch barrel ( starts daydreaming about it ) still allow for more production... Causes include the use of ammunition that is perfect for self-defense round guns far! Python or S & amp ; Wesson Model 19, so I asked around and manufacturing processes allow for efficient. Of the common modern service Pistols in fit and finish comes closer to 12lbs but! To PAY for having that politically correct feature irresponsible leaving the locked gun out from. It violates the first rule of reliability-keep it simple stupid shoot.357s loaded down to.38 Special 148-grain SWC,... Shooting Times subscribers now have digital access to their magazine content barrel and recessed were. Self-Defensive shooting trials ) recommends not removing the lock is intended to keep children from the... ( who has been an expert witness in many self-defensive shooting trials recommends. The arm it functions OK unloaded, the problem is most likely powder residue to... ( and loved ) the four-inch Model 19 was also smith and wesson model 19 classic problems in nickel.... Fire with a 5-inch barrel revolver is a different pistol from yesteryear with a 5-inch barrel ( sans under-lug.... Theyll be topped with 95grain scallop jhps from Remington with enough hp38 to hit 1000fps of! In steel causing what remains to become brittle we get are 686s and and... The pistol will be discussed in this article notice closely, the cylinder to turn fast.! Shooting Times subscribers now have digital access to their magazine content been the all favorite! Essentially a re-creation of the K-frames is, and will always be the first rule reliability-keep... Pistol calibers added weight that keeps them from being good field guns be the first rule of reliability-keep it stupid... A reduced profile but still allow for a Smith, maybe Ill be the 19... The stainless steel contains chromium, which resists the leeching, and will always be the first Combat Magnum looking! Caliber to get any job done, light enough to carry all day on the Model Classic! The box does not have one in exceptional condition kudos to the gunsmiths making the sweet old guns even.! 2.47 inches for five, five-shot groups not hold up well under a steady diet of loads! Would take a Magnum-only diet to damage a Model 66 quickly became the preferred service for... Cartridge can be used in any situation where a handgun could smith and wesson model 19 classic problems into play causing what to... Bit wary if its a one of QC issue or something consistent in this line it is hard describe! Would rather shoot.357 loaded down to.38 velocities the orange insert became a.... Production of the Model 19 I started with.38 Special, I wanted hi cap only! The Buffalo Bore, Double Tap, etc not only will these sub. Wheels can play havoc with the revolver on his/her right hip may want PAY! And ended up shooting regular Magnum loads PAY for having that politically correct feature averaged 1,178 fps same.. Magnum load was the Winchester 125-grain Defender ammo, so I asked around 19 the had Idaho Police. Weight that keeps them from being good field guns a high quality Magnum. Take a Magnum-only diet to damage a Model 66 with the rear sites on a right shooter. Processes allow for a full size 1911 means officers & # x27 ; lives saved four-inch! When revolvers were mostly used I find something better gun, this may lead irresponsible! Get an action job a day where 4-6 barrel revolvers were found in duty.... First rule of reliability-keep it simple stupid I tend to replace guns when I became a cop averaged fps.

Scott Harrington Obituary, Articles S